Válasz erre: Krónikák egy másik világból III.

News Fórumok Az emberiség rejtélyei Összeesküvés elméletek Krónikák egy másik világból III. Válasz erre: Krónikák egy másik világból III.

#27632
istvanka85
Felhasználó

Kecskeb?völ?k és az ablaknak csapódó madár

“Techne and Gnosis”

“1. I also had asked why it is that Plato regards art (techne) as contrasting with knowledge (episteme), but apparently not with knowledge (gnosis). And I had asked similarly why he regards opinion (doxa) as contrasting with knowledge (episteme), but apparently not with knowledge (gnosis).

The answer to my techne question seems to follow directly from your explanation: “[E]pisteme is . . . a special knowledge (the episteme of a doctor, for example) . . .” It would naturally follow that differing fields have differing sciences. So we could have your episteme of a doctor, as well as a differing episteme of the statesman. Then, parallel with this, differing activities have differing arts. So we have the arts (techne) of shoe-making, of pottery, etc. Moreover, if we have a specific field or activity – ship navigation, rhetoric, etc. – we can naturally ask if it is an art (techne) or a science (episteme). If I’m not mistaken, Plato would say that ‘gnosis’ behaves differently. It’s not that there is one gnosis of this field and some other gnosis of some other field. Rather, gnosis is just gnosis. And it would be for this reason that field-specific techne would naturally contrast with field-specific episteme but not with gnosis.

I’m less confident I can see why Plato contrasts doxa with episteme, but apparently not with gnosis. When he makes this contrast, he seems to be saying that episteme is knowledge of things in light of reasons (principles, causes), whereas doxa is not based in reasons. But what then of gnosis? Let me at this point take a guess: gnosis is like doxa in that it is not based in reasons; it differs in that doxa can be true or false, whereas gnosis is always true. Am I wrong in this guess?”

***

Okoztál már gondolattal balesetet vagy súlyosabbat?

Az a lényeg, hogy vigyázz a gondolataidra.

A Gondolatok X, Z, Y rendszerben is hatnak és ez scak az alap és nem id? és nem távolságfügg?.

***

A film elején is szólnak egy felírattal (a focipálya jelenet sem annyira vicces), hogy ez nem vicc, csak a moziban néz?téren gyak. senki nem figyel.